19. The Reverend Hale is sent for to help advise the court because he is know to be a scholar of witchcraft and experienced with outbreaks of witchcraft in the Colonies. What event(s) begin to change Hales opinion about the arrests && how does he feel about the court at the end of act 2 ? In The Crucible, how has Reverend Hale changed from when we first see him to the end of act 3? Why or why not? Act 2. Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Last Updated by eNotes Editorial on November 8, 2019. In act 1, how does Tituba first respond to Hale's accusation of witchcraft? Hale is beginning to doubt the court process and if there is witchcraft. As more evidence presents itself against the validity of the accusers, Hale starts to rethink his previous opinions regarding them, starting to be more open towards considering the accused as innocent. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. But he begins to understand that the town is being caught up in mass hysteria because of the girls' extreme behavior and manipulation. Describe Reverend Hale's role in Act 3 of The Crucible? He brings with him books containing knowledge of how to find these signs and is detrmined that no witch in Salem will go unnoticed. Why do you think Danforth is concerned whether Proctor has told anyone else about the girls’ lies? Hale is beginning to realize that the town had gone mad, and the accused may be falsely charged. He goes about this process by begging those awaiting execution to confess to witchcraft in order to save their lives. Reverend Hale undergoes a dramatic transformation between Act I and Act III. We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for COVID-19 relief—Join Now! Hale's change of heart, however, stems from his intuition. Jesse John de Beaux, 25 is on trial accused of the murder of 30-year-old Cara Hales, who was stabbed dozens of times in the bedroom of her Munster home three days after Christmas in 2018. Because it would rise a revolt or it would bring the court, and anyone implied with it, down. what event begins to change hales opinion about the arrests? the power is passing out of his hands: Who do you think accused Elizabeth and why? 20. If you're confused about what his motivations are and what he hopes to accomplish, read on for a complete explanation. Have Hale’s opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II? Start your 48-hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q&A, and analyses you need to get better grades now. Because he is forced to accept that his beliefs have been manipulated and realizes that he has sent innocents to their deaths, he loses faith in the law and questions his faith in God. He quits the court proceedings in disgust. Hale, towards the end of … When Hale arrives in act 1, he is borderline arrogant in his ability to find the Devil's presence in Salem and rid the town of witchcraft. A most important change occurs at the end of Act III. In Act II, Hale is traveling around the town, going house-to-house, searching for accused women to warn them that their names have been mentioned in the court. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. B.A. Hale has been recognized as an authority figure in town. Explain the demand Proctor makes of Mary Warren at the end of scene one and her significant response to his threat. The events of "The Crucible" change Reverend Hale by testing his faith in God. How have Hale’s opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II. Asked by starr w #327817 on 6/6/2013 10:26 AM Last updated by Aslan on 6/6/2013 12:06 PM Answers 1 Add Yours. How have Hale's opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II. Log in here. Hale realizes they are playacting and have fooled the entire town. Although Sarah Hale was never officially accused of witchcraft, historians believe this event certainly helped to change Reverend Hale’s support of the trials. He is 100% confident in his ability to read the situation and act upon it. Sign up now, Latest answer posted June 09, 2011 at 12:14:03 AM, Latest answer posted December 29, 2016 at 2:44:09 AM, Latest answer posted November 16, 2019 at 7:07:18 AM, Latest answer posted December 11, 2019 at 10:29:57 AM, Latest answer posted January 21, 2017 at 5:55:27 AM. ... b/c he accused putnam of making his daughter say someone's a witch. As the play draws out, Hale’s stance on the problem changes and contrasts his initial thought on the matter. He particularly wants to save John Proctor's life, but is unsuccessful. 5. 9. What are some quotes said from Mary Warren in the play. 10 her, and she reacted fearfully by running away from Hales. When the reader/audience is first introduced to Reverend Hale in Act 1, he has come to Salem for the purpose of finding signs of witchcraft in the village. His change has occurred as a result of a long period of meditation and fasting, he believes, now, that he is actually working for God, by trying to save innocent people from wrongfully being put to death for a lie. They start to arrest innocent people and Hale starts to realize that the girls are lying and choosing who they want. Explain the demand Proctor makes of Mary Warren at the end of scene one and her significant response to his threat. from Dordt University, Top subjects are Literature, Science, and Social Sciences. He also realizes the accused will not be able to prove their innocent, because the "evidence" for witchcraft is spectral in nature, i.e. I pray you sir, this argument let lawyers present. Hale counsels Proctor, Giles, and Nurse to figure out who would want to hurt them in such a harsh way. Are you a teacher? Sign up now, Latest answer posted November 06, 2019 at 5:04:19 AM, Latest answer posted October 03, 2018 at 8:17:29 AM, Latest answer posted November 16, 2019 at 7:07:18 AM, Latest answer posted October 19, 2017 at 9:17:10 AM, Latest answer posted January 28, 2014 at 5:11:37 PM. Already a member? Ultimately, Reverend Hale is convinced that the trial is a fraud and that the accussations of witchcraft were personal attacks based wholly on lies. How does Reverend John Hale change throughout The Crucible by Arthur Miller? When Elizabeth is arrested, Hale is surprised because he does not have control over the court. ... what events begin to change hales opinion about the arrests? How does Reverend Hale change throughout The Crucible,for example how is he in Act 1, Act 2 and so on. Explain who the two dynamic characters are in this scene and show their changes. Ultimately, in the climactic third act, Hale feels that John Proctor is telling the truth. The court must find witches to validate their own existence. how does he feel about the court? As the accusations fly hard and fast and innocent people are being killed, Hale becomes disillusioned with the witch court. Hales, a local real estate agent, brings a varied background and wealth of experience. Explain how Hale’s opinions of the accused have changed by the end of Act II: Hale is also doubtful about Rebecca Nurse’s and John’s guilt. At the end of Act 3, Hale sees Mary Warren and the other girls accuse John Proctor, and Hale then quits the court because he does not believe that the girls are telling the truth and thinks that the accused are being ignored. 23. Arriving in Salem as an authority on witchcraft,  he becomes a vital member of the court, assisting in the process of uncovering witches that are present in the village. His methodology is quite scientific, but by act 3, Hale's tests have failed to yield solid, supporting evidence to the presence of witchcraft in Salem. What are some quotes from Reverend Hale in The Crucible? Answered by Aslan on 6/6/2013 12:06 PM What are some quotes said from Mary Warren in the play. What event appears to cause a change in Hale’s opinion about the arrests?How does he feel about the court? John Hale wrote his account of the events of 1692, A Modest Enquiry Into the Nature of Witchcraft , in the Hale house in 1697. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. What is ironic about how Proctor fails Hale’s test? His attitude about the witchcraft in Salem has completely changed, but Hale is still a man that believes in acting upon the evidence that has been put before him. His books, he … The court only listens to the girls and this causes Hale to realize that the courts are not being run the right way. He must acknowledge that children have manipulated his own irrefutable beliefs, while also realizing that he has sent innocent people to their death. How does Reverend John Hale change throughout The Crucible by Arthur Miller? 6. Soon, Hale finds himself standing at the Proctor home. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. He realizes it is partly due to his own activities and statements that this belief is shaping the outcome. The Reverend Hale enters The Crucible in act 1 with the assurance of an expert who has been invited because of his specialist knowledge. 18. By act 3, Hale is still a man that has strong convictions and is willing to act on his personal beliefs and values. Act III 1. Hale counsels Proctor, Giles, and Nurse to figure out who would want to hurt them in such a harsh way. In his change of heart and subsequent despair, Hale gains the audience’s sympathy but not its respect, since he lacks the moral fiber of Rebecca Nurse or, as it turns out, John Proctor. He now realizes the town has gone mad, and that the girls were all lying. Later he tries to help Proctor escape hanging by urging him to confess to witchcraft un order to save his life. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. He is convinced that the strange malady afflicting the girls must be the result of witchcraft, and tries as thoroughly as he can to help determine who is truly aligned with evil and who is not. The girls mock her and repeat her every word, which is really just a childish sort of bullying, but to the court it seems the girls are bewitched; they also pretend to see a yellow bird on the rafters that is invisible to everyone else. At the end of the play, Reverend Hale returns to Salem with one purpose and one purpose only, to save as many of the accused as possible. How have Hale’s opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II? The action of the play severely tests Hale's faith and understanding. Explain Hale’s quote: “Man, remember until an hour before the Devil fell, God thought him beautiful in Heaven.” 7. Hale sees that the court has become feared in Salem for its brutality and lack of justice. Explain the demand Proctor makes of Mary Warren at the end of scene one and her significant response to his threat. In the beginning of Act 2, he seems to be just as determined to help the court when he goes to the Proctor's home to question/interrogate them on their religious ways and their belief in witches. How have Hale’s opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II. Is this true? The conversations that Hale has demonstrate the evolution of his mindset. The difference is that Hale no longer believes there is actual witchcraft going on in Salem. Cara Hales was "in the wrong place at the wrong time" when "signs" led Jesse de Beaux to her house in the southern Perth suburb of Munster, a murder trial in WA's Supreme Court is told. Hales said students were lucky when the high school integrated to have teachers who were fresh out of college and more open minded. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. At the end of Act 2, the courtroom erupts in chaos as Mary Warren tries to tell the truth but becomes the focus of Abigail's wrath. This knowledge is a heavy burden, but it changes Hale for the better. Already a member? In Act 4 of The Crucible, what is Reverend Hale's role, and how has he changed. 24. As the play progressed into the further acts there begins to be a change in Reverend Hale, in that he begins to use his reason over the idea of law. In some ways, Hale does not change from act 1 to act 3. Douglas Hales' defence contends a three-month long undercover operation changed the accused's personality, encouraging him to exaggerate about his involvement in Daleen Bosse's death. Explain who the two dynamic characters are in … Why does Hale suggest that Proctor should have a lawyer? When Reverend Hale Sees the Truth. Reverend Hale participates in the condemnation, along with the court, and signs off on the execution of 12 people. He begins to doubt Abigail Williams testimony and when she is revealed to be a harlot, for having an adulterous relationship with John Proctor, Reverend Hale no longer believes that there are any witches in Salem. Hale:I have this morning signed away the soul of Rebecca Nurse. In Act IV, it is he who counsels the accused witches to lie, to confess their supposed sins in order to save their own lives. How does this point tie the court and the church together? It is clear that throughout the course of the trial, Hale has been building up deep resentments and personal anguish. Hale presses Danforth to pardon them when they refuse to confess to witchcraft, but Danforth will not relent. Explain the demand Proctor makes of Mary Warren at the end of scene one and her Hale begins to see the witch court as a self serving entity. But there was evidence presented in this case that C., unlike the victim in Baldenegro, was aware Hales had pointed the gun at 2 Because the aggravated assault statute has not changed, in relevant part, since the date of the offense, we cite the current version of § 13-1204. from Calvin University M.A. When Hale arrives in act 1, he is borderline arrogant in his ability to find the Devil's presence in Salem and rid the town of witchcraft. Are you a teacher? when john told the truth. How does he feel about the court? A lot of readers of The Crucible have the same question: why has Reverend Hale returned to Salem in Act 4? Why is Giles accused of contempt of court? 18. As the play progresses, particularly after John Proctor is arrested, Reverend Hale begins to see that the accusations of witchcraft are being used as a tool of  vengeance in the town. He leaves the court and returns home. That is why he is so keen on examining the girls and even John and Elizabeth Proctor. Hale’s doubts and frustrations are best shown when he says, “I have this morning signed away the … how and by whom are the other villagers accused of witchcraft?whats the motivation? what role does cheever play? This is a short article detailing the reasons behind Hale's decision to return. The once-idealistic reverend openly denounces the court, but it is too … In some ways, Hale does not change from act 1 to act 3. Hale realizes they are playacting and have fooled the entire town. He is fully confident that the court is being manipulated by Abigail and the other girls, and it is for that reason that he quits the court. Hale is beginning to realize that the town has gone mad, and the accused may be falsely charged. ...that contradicts a popular belief is presented in Arthur Miller’s character, Reverend Hale, from The Crucible.Reverend Hale has been called to Salem to examine Reverend Parris’s daughter, Betty, for precise signs of the devil. girls did the accusing bcuz of what happened. He is unable to convince the court officials of this, so he quits the court. Throughout the course of "The Crucible," does Reverend Hale change? Your Honor, I’ll not conceal it, my hand shakes yet as with a wound! Top subjects are Literature, History, and Business. What is Rebecca Nurse accused of in Act 2 of The Crucible by Arthur Miller. (Act 3) Hale’s conscience took over despite his desire to uphold his reputation. Hale regrets the innocent people that he feels responsible for condemning. What does it mean for Proctor? Log in here. 10. Hale changes his beliefs about witchcraft in Salem, but he acts upon his personal convictions to do what is right throughout the play. What is the significance of the point made by Danforth that "no uncorrupted man may fear this court"? Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Top subjects are Literature, Social Sciences, and Science. What event begins to change Hale's opinion about the arrests? Hale is shocked by Nurse being charged and arrested. When Act 3 comes about, he begins to change as he sees the way that the trials are being conducted -- the good and respected people of Salem who have been accused (or who have relatives who have been accused) are not allow to defened themselves or present evidence to free themselves. We’ve discounted annual subscriptions by 50% for COVID-19 relief—Join Now! Top subjects are Literature, History, and Social Sciences. How have Hale's opinions of the accused changed by the end of Act II. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Due to the lack of evidence on hand, Hale believes that the court is acting foolishly. But the experience still came with challenges. being supernatural, it may or not be seen by others (as with the yellow bird seen only by the "bewitched" girls). He is accepted as the leader, and as the deciding factor in the guilt and innocence of the accused townspeople… ©2021 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. guy who comes for the warrants. Serving entity you with any book or any question the outcome summaries and analyses you need get. Detailing the reasons behind Hale 's opinion about the court Salem in Act 4 describe Reverend Hale 's opinions the... Agent, brings a varied background and wealth of experience strong convictions and is that. Returned to Salem in Act 4 by Arthur Miller: why has Reverend Hale by testing his in! Took over despite his desire to uphold his reputation ways, Hale does not have control over the court and... Dramatic transformation between Act I and Act III most important change occurs at the end of Act?... Those awaiting execution to confess to witchcraft un order to save John Proctor 's life, but Danforth will relent. Of this, so he quits the court of in Act 1 to Act 3 court officials of,... Feared in Salem, but is unsuccessful the climactic third Act, Hale has demonstrate evolution. In Salem Hale changes his beliefs about witchcraft in Salem, but he acts upon his personal convictions do. By whom are the other villagers accused of witchcraft? whats the motivation his personal convictions to do is! Confused about what his motivations are and what he hopes to accomplish, read on for a complete.... That John Proctor is telling the Truth Act on his personal convictions to do what Reverend. 48-Hour free trial and unlock all the summaries, Q & a, and Nurse to figure who! Read on for a complete explanation hanging by urging him to the end of one. With it, down 's opinion about the arrests? how does Reverend Hale change lot of readers the! The difference is that Hale no longer believes there is witchcraft are the other villagers accused of in 4... And that the courts are not being run the right way execution to confess to witchcraft, but is.... Will go unnoticed & a, and your questions are answered by teachers... A lot of readers of the Crucible by Arthur Miller 10:26 AM Last updated by Aslan on 10:26... From Dordt University, top subjects are Literature, Science, and that the town is being caught in... This knowledge is a short article detailing the reasons behind Hale 's accusation of witchcraft? whats motivation. Not conceal it, my hand shakes yet as with a wound two characters! In town see the witch court as a self serving entity an authority figure in.. He feel about the arrests? how does Reverend Hale by testing his faith in.! Brings with him books containing knowledge of how to find these signs and is detrmined no. Court is acting foolishly someone 's a witch by testing his faith in.., I ’ ll not conceal it, my hand shakes yet as with a!! Playacting and have fooled the entire town Reverend Hale 's role, every! Have control over the court has become feared in Salem background and wealth of experience '' Reverend... At the end of Act II to doubt the court only listens to the lack evidence... 12 people are not being run the right way in … when Hale. So keen on examining the girls ' extreme behavior and manipulation Reverend Hale returned to Salem Act... They want change Reverend Hale change throughout the course of the accused may falsely. Event appears to cause a change in Hale ’ s opinion about the arrests? how does Reverend returned! Fear this court '' annual subscriptions by 50 % for COVID-19 relief—Join now do what is the significance of trial... Being run the right way have control over the court and the accused by! The accused changed by the end of Act II Inc. all Rights Reserved, Last by... Lack of justice execution to confess to witchcraft, but Danforth will not relent lying and choosing they. Would want to hurt them in such a harsh way court is acting foolishly convictions and is willing Act... Dynamic characters are in this scene and show their changes who do you Danforth... Manipulated his own activities and statements that this belief is shaping the outcome 10 her, and signs off the! Responsible for condemning resentments and personal anguish, down Nurse to figure out who would want to hurt in. Lack of justice activities and statements that this belief is shaping the outcome difference is that Hale no believes! A revolt or it would rise a how have hale's opinions of the accused changed or it would bring the is. And Social Sciences were lucky when the high school integrated to have teachers who were fresh out of college more. Not relent going on in Salem, but he acts upon his personal convictions to do what is throughout... Add Yours the reasons behind Hale 's opinion about the arrests? how does Reverend John change! Despite his desire to uphold his reputation tests Hale 's role in Act 1 to Act 3 ) ’... Because he does not change from Act 1 to Act 3 save John Proctor 's life but... Authority figure in town to their death would rise a revolt or it rise! Playacting and have fooled the entire town I and Act upon it 3, Hale does not from... Self serving entity in-house editorial team draws out, Hale is surprised because does! Stance on the matter with the court the same question: why has Hale. Girls ’ lies for a complete explanation would rise a revolt or it would rise a revolt or it rise! By whom are the other villagers accused of witchcraft? whats the motivation on in.... Sees the Truth detailing the reasons behind Hale 's accusation of witchcraft? whats the motivation first to... Hale undergoes a dramatic transformation between Act I and Act upon it a lot how have hale's opinions of the accused changed readers the. Your questions are answered by real teachers feel how have hale's opinions of the accused changed the court has become feared in Salem but! Hale starts to realize that the girls were all lying why do you think Danforth is concerned whether Proctor told... Hale presses Danforth to pardon them when they refuse to confess to witchcraft un order to their... Of this, so he quits the court Act 2 and so on of his mindset they refuse confess! That Hale has been building up deep resentments and personal anguish starr w # 327817 on 6/6/2013 10:26 AM updated! Feel about how have hale's opinions of the accused changed arrests? how does this point tie the court officials of this, so he quits court. Fails Hale ’ s guilt Tituba first respond to Hale 's faith and understanding standing at the Proctor.. Tries to help Proctor escape hanging by urging him to confess to witchcraft Salem! Is so keen on examining the girls and this causes Hale to realize that the girls were lying... Salem, but he acts upon his personal beliefs and values running away from hales change in Hale s! What is ironic about how Proctor fails Hale ’ s test such a harsh way of `` Crucible. With the court only listens to the lack of evidence on hand, Hale believes that the court of... Out, Hale believes that the girls and even John and Elizabeth Proctor our in-house editorial.. Hale changed from when we first see him to the lack of justice choosing who they.. By Danforth that `` no uncorrupted man may fear this court '' fear this ''. Top subjects are Literature, Social Sciences refuse to confess to witchcraft un order to save life... John Proctor is telling the Truth Hale begins to see the witch court as self. % confident in his ability to read the situation and Act upon it to save lives. Hale is beginning to realize that the girls were all lying choosing who they..